The Case for Doing Less
Decades of research show that actively managed funds โ where a portfolio manager picks stocks โ underperform simple index funds over long periods. A 2023 S&P SPIVA report found that over 15 years, more than 88% of US large-cap fund managers underperformed the S&P 500 index.
You don't need a stock picker. You need a low-cost index fund and the discipline to leave it alone.
What Is Passive Investing?
Passive investing means owning a broad index โ typically the total US stock market, or the S&P 500 โ through a low-cost fund, and holding it for years without trading. The goal is to capture the market's return, not to beat it.
The three key principles:
- Diversification โ own thousands of stocks, not a handful
- Low costs โ expense ratios of 0.03โ0.05% vs. 0.5โ1%+ for actively managed funds
- Patience โ don't sell when markets drop; time in the market beats timing the market
Robo-Advisors: Passive Investing on Autopilot
A robo-advisor is an automated investment platform that builds and manages a diversified portfolio based on your risk tolerance and timeline. It handles allocation, rebalancing, and (in premium tiers) tax-loss harvesting โ all without you needing to make ongoing decisions.
The main platforms:
- Betterment โ strong tax-loss harvesting, goal-based accounts, $0 minimum
- Wealthfront โ Path financial planning tool, direct indexing at $100K+, $500 minimum
- Schwab Intelligent Portfolios โ no advisory fee (uses Schwab's own funds), $5,000 minimum
Robo-advisor fees of 0.25%/year are higher than DIY index fund investing but lower than human advisors (1%+), and the automation value is real for investors who lack the discipline to rebalance manually.
The DIY Alternative: Three-Fund Portfolio
The simplest passive investing strategy that doesn't require a robo-advisor:
- US total market index fund โ VTI, FZROX, or SWTSX (0โ0.03% expense ratio)
- International total market index fund โ VXUS or FZILX (0.07โ0.08% expense ratio)
- Bond index fund โ BND or FXNAX (0.03โ0.05% expense ratio)
Allocate based on your timeline: further from retirement = more stocks, less bonds. Rebalance once a year to your target allocation. That's it.
What Passive Investing Is Not
- It is not guaranteed returns โ markets decline, sometimes significantly
- It is not zero risk โ a total market fund will lose 30โ50% in a major bear market
- It does not require you to stop contributing โ automated monthly contributions into index funds is the ideal implementation
Investing
Ready to start investing?
Compare brokers, robo-advisors, and IRAs matched to your goals.
About the author
David Freedland
CFPยฎ ยท Senior Editor, Personal Finance
David Freedland has over 12 years of experience reviewing consumer financial products across credit, lending, insurance, and investing. He has contributed to multiple personal finance publications. His methodology focuses on total cost of ownership, not promotional rate windows.
Full bio & credentials โโจ Find the right product, faster
Credit cards, savings, loans, insurance, and investments โ compared side by side. Free, forever.
Credit cards
Rewards, cash back & balance transfer
Savings accounts
Top APY rates compared
Personal loans
Best rates for every credit score
Insurance
Auto, home, life & more
Investing
Brokers, robo-advisors & ETFs
Auto loans
New, used & refinance
Credit cards
Rewards, cash back & balance transfer
Savings accounts
Top APY rates compared
Personal loans
Best rates for every credit score
Insurance
Auto, home, life & more
Investing
Brokers, robo-advisors & ETFs
Auto loans
New, used & refinance
Related guides
Best ESG Investing Platforms (2026)
Socially responsible investing โ how to align your portfolio with your values
Best Platforms for Dividend Investing (2026)
DRIP programs, dividend yield, and the brokers that make income investing easiest
Best Investing Accounts for Retirement (2026)
IRAs, 401(k)s, and Roth accounts โ how to maximize tax-advantaged retirement savings